Remove this ad
avatar

TheRoonBa

Posts: 5,454 Site Admin

#42 [url]

Sep 14 15 12:52 AM

I removed the 8.9 Zambia v Gabon match as an A match. Gabon did not send their A team due to flight problems, and sent a hastily assembled local-based team instead (they still managed to get a 1-1 draw and then beat Rwanda 1-0 on 12.9). Rwanda was also preparing for the 2016 CHAN tournament, so Rwanda v Gabon was really a CHAN v CHAN friendly.


Gabon lineup for Zambia:
StéphaneBitséki (C)-Edmond Mouélé, Barel Ngandjouma, Wilfrid Ebane Abessolo, Cyril Avebe-Tchen Kabi, Knox Younga, David Massamba-Romuald Ntsitsigui, Axel Meye (74e Rick Mba Allogho), Romaric Rogombé (85e Franck Obambou).

Gabon lineup for Sudan:
OVONO, APPINDANGOYE, ECUELE MANGA, EVOUNA, PALUN, AUBAMEYANG (C), MADINDA, KANGA, MBINGUI, ZE ONDO, POKO
Substitutes: MFA MEZUI, MUSAVU KING, TANDJIGORA, OBIANG, OTO'O ZUE, NTSITSIGUI, LENGOUALAMA

Not a single player was in both teams.

Last Edited By: TheRoonBa Sep 14 15 1:00 AM. Edited 1 time.

Quote    Reply   

#43 [url]

Sep 15 15 10:49 AM

No player was in both teams simply because they are two completely separate teams. How about considering "Gabon" and "Gabon CHAN" as separate teams in the records and rankings etc. Like IFFHS did with "England" and "England Amateur".

Quote    Reply   
avatar

TheRoonBa

Posts: 5,454 Site Admin

#44 [url]

Sep 15 15 5:22 PM

That suits me fine - but the matches were classed as Tier 1 matches by FIFA beforehand (due to the forms handed in having "Tier 1" written on them), and it seems they can't change them afterwards. In any case, Gabon possibly got better results with their CHAN team than they would have with their A team.

For me, dividing matches into Tier 1 and Tier 2 is a good solution - the only problem is that some countries (those that bother to keep track of these things) treat 'CHAN' friendly matches as Tier 2 matches and some treat them as Tier 1 matches (thus countable by FIFA in the official records). So, there is no consistency (nothing new there).

Quote    Reply   

#46 [url]

Sep 16 15 8:41 AM

When I googled for FIFA Tier 1 I found this. To me it appears to be suitable into the favourite Toon Hermans (1916-2000) who was a brilliant conferencier)) terms: why doing things the easy way if you can do it the difficult way. It seems to me any match can be a Tier 1 by filling in the Tier 1 application form.

The Tier 1, 2 and 3 thing won't make this discussion easier.

Quote    Reply   

#47 [url]

Sep 16 15 10:42 AM

Every few years, some new uninitiated clown takes charge of these matters at FIFA and tries to "solve" the existing mess (caused by bad protocol) by inventing a new bad protocol to replace the old bad protocol. Even if the new protocol is better in any way, the general confusion caused by the continual changes undermines any potential improvements, and the mess gets worse.

Somehow this reminds me of a Christmas letter to Santa:
Please may I have a new old jumper. My old jumper is old.

Quote    Reply   

#48 [url]

Sep 16 15 10:46 AM

Fast Midfielder wrote:
It seems to me any match can be a Tier 1 by filling in the Tier 1 application form.
... The head of delegation shall be a natural person ...

This is unfair discrimination against cyborgs, or indeed anybody with an artificial hip or implant of some kind.

Quote    Reply   
Remove this ad
avatar

TheRoonBa

Posts: 5,454 Site Admin

#50 [url]

Sep 17 15 2:33 PM

I have given up trying to talk logically about this subject. It's impossible to get anything changed, as there is always a thick layer of bureaucracy. It reminds me a bit of that game where you pull out straws and try to avoid making the whole structure collapse.

Quote    Reply   

#51 [url]

Sep 17 15 4:41 PM

i think it's more like trying to shape a pile of rubble into a structure of some kind. At best a sort of dry-stone wall is possible, before a slight breeze restores the entropy.

Quote    Reply   
avatar

TheRoonBa

Posts: 5,454 Site Admin

#52 [url]

Sep 21 15 9:17 PM

In biological terms, it's like pissing in the sea. Some small crustaceans and fish may sense a slight change in the water they are swimming through, but at the end of the day, they just get on with what they were doing before, and the sea washes away any trace that anything happened.

Quote    Reply   
avatar

TheRoonBa

Posts: 5,454 Site Admin

#55 [url]

Jun 25 16 6:06 PM

I've removed the Angola matches from the COSAFA Cup. Angola used their U-20 team (like they did in 2013). Their results were pretty bad this time (0-3 to Malawi, 0-2 to Lesotho and 0-2 to Mauritius).

Quote    Reply   
avatar

TheRoonBa

Posts: 5,454 Site Admin

#56 [url]

I'm not counting Mexico-Croatia as an A match. Croatia's team against Mexico is almost completely different from their team selected to play Iceland in WCQ, with 10 players having 0 caps. Only 4 players are in the squad for both matches. The highest-capped player for the Mexico match has only 9 caps, 2 players have 7 caps, and 3 have 2 caps. All the rest are uncapped. This is clearly a Croatia 'B' team, similar to the team that played in the China Cup in January.

Quote    Reply   
Remove this ad
Add Reply

Quick Reply

bbcode help