here my answers: "How can you define a strong team( or line up)..?? it's just partial, a national trainer can use some youth players To test in a friendly game and it can still be an A game....we have to understand that Football isn't a science, that lineups can vary due to numerous reasons " injuries, trainer choices.." so , as a matter of fact, we'll never reach a top notch team, because players are human beings and can't always be the best....So your definition of an A game, can't be based on this criterea.... "
That's very true. And a lot of full A internationals that everyone regard official A - in particular the friendlies - have been such kind of matches.
"i see that it's mainly the job of FIFA, and the FAs involved, it's up to consider if it is an official game or not, since FIFA created FIFA days to compete, so i think it's more official when FIFA consider it so."
Here I don't agree. Read my item about Norway 7-0 France, 11 June 1922 issue. I think it's childish why FIFA, after insisting by FFF, deleted this match.
"Tunisia played a friendly game against Italy on 2004 , and we lost 0/4 although we didn't play with the " top notch team" ( ES Tunis and ES Sahel players didn't play due to African Clubs Cup, as some professional players who played in foreign countries had their vacations at the time of the game..), but we considered it as an A game, by both sides and by FIFA as an A game, even we can say that Tunisia played with a B team, who didn't have the strentgh to make one attack, against a full sided Italy ( Del Piero, Totti, Pirlo, Cannavaro, Buffon...)"
This is an "A"match. My country, Netherland, also played for the reason you meant with weakened sides. 1995 N 0-1 Portugal, without 8 players from Ajax. 1999 N 1-2 Morocco, without 6 players from Barcelona. A lot of such matches have ben played and are regarded official A by everybody. In the 1960s NL played many official A matches without the likes of Ajax, as they refused to play for the national team because the club had other priorities. And this are just NL examples. Hundreds of such matches have been played.